Dark Alley review

Dark Alley is a detective adventure set in Kyoto, Japan, where British investigator Thomas Bennett is searching for a missing compatriot with alleged connections to the yakuza. Sporting a trench coat, an unfortunate hat and an attitude that could sour a family gathering, Bennett is hardly the most appealing detective. Sadly, the game surrounding him isn’t much better.

Gaming Heaven

The first-person perspective offers a little freedom to explore, while the visual-novel conversations provide some variety. Locations have a reasonable amount of detail, and the talking-head presentation gives the dialogue a recognisable identity. There’s also a notebook documenting your objectives, which is useful when the game occasionally forgets to explain what you’re supposed to be doing.

The basic detective premise has potential, and moving between environments to investigate clues could have made for an enjoyable little mystery. Unfortunately, potential is doing an awful lot of work here.

Gaming Hell

The puzzles are painfully linear, with objectives offering little guidance beyond vague instructions. You’ll spend much of your time wandering around small environments looking for objects that conveniently solve whatever problem happens to be blocking your path. Picking up items can be particularly confusing, especially when things such as bricks mysteriously disappear without explanation.

There’s also very little happening around you. Kyoto feels deserted, locations lack meaningful interaction, and the occasional action sequence is so limited it barely qualifies as gameplay. Bennett’s repetitive, sarcastic responses quickly become irritating, while the dialogue and character portrayals lean heavily on tired cultural stereotypes. The whole experience feels unfinished, as though somebody submitted the first draft and everyone went home.

Final Judgement

Dark Alley has the foundations of an interesting detective adventure, but its weak writing, shallow gameplay and uninspired puzzles make it difficult to recommend. The protagonist is irritating, the world feels lifeless and the investigation rarely provides much satisfaction. If you’re after a gripping crime thriller, you’d be better off watching a decent detective series. At least then the characters might have something interesting to say.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *