
After 15 years in development, Asylum has finally escaped the development ward and arrived on PS5. Unfortunately, spending that long locked away doesn’t automatically produce a masterpiece. You return to Hanwell Mental Institute, hoping to uncover forgotten memories and disturbing secrets. What follows is a first-person horror adventure that occasionally feels more like an appointment you can’t cancel.
Gaming Heaven
Hanwell is certainly atmospheric. Its decaying corridors, disturbing history, unsettling screams and gloomy soundtrack create an appropriately uncomfortable environment. The deliberately dated, VHS-inspired visuals also give the game a distinctive appearance, even if they occasionally resemble footage recovered from somebody’s neglected attic.
Some puzzles are reasonably logical, while the narrative contains a few interesting developments. There’s clearly been considerable effort put into recreating the institute’s architectural design, and the setting does most of the heavy lifting.

Gaming Hell
Unfortunately, there’s an awful lot of heavy lifting. Hanwell is enormous, and wandering repeatedly between rooms becomes tedious remarkably quickly. The limited interaction with the environment makes much of this exploration feel pointless, as though you’re conducting a guided tour with absolutely no idea where the exit is.
The item-selection system is awkward, puzzles can become irritating without a hint system, and certain challenges amount to little more than finding the correct mechanism to open another door. The writing is inconsistent, and despite a lengthy campaign, the story leaves too many questions unanswered. Ambiguity can be clever, but occasionally it just feels like somebody forgot to finish explaining things.
Final Judgement
Asylum has atmosphere and an interesting premise, but its sluggish exploration, repetitive backtracking and frustrating puzzle design undermine the experience. Fifteen years of development have produced something with occasional promise, rather than the horror classic its supporters might have hoped for. Not quite a nightmare, then, but certainly a long and rather tedious night shift.